I got these for my dog as she was becoming forgetful and as times not making it outside in time.they were great I just added a nighttime incontinent pad and they worked fine. Sadly our Bella crossed the rainbow bridge yesterday, we are devastated at the loss of our baby girl, she had a good life and was just shy of her 16th birthday. There is a big gap in our home now, I find myself looking for her automatically as I do my chores.